For many Toronto residents, long-term disability (LTD) benefits are meant to provide financial stability during some of life’s most difficult moments. When illness or injury prevents you from working, disability insurance is supposed to step in and replace a portion of your income.
But what happens when your claim is denied?
Unfortunately, long-term disability claims are denied more often than people expect. Many individuals who genuinely cannot work receive letters stating their claim has been rejected or their benefits have been terminated. Understanding why this happens is the first step toward protecting yourself.
Let’s take a closer look at the most common reasons long-term disability claims are denied in Toronto — and how speaking with a long-term disability claims lawyer can help you understand your options and protect your rights if your benefits are refused.
1. Insufficient Medical Evidence
One of the most common reasons LTD claims are denied is a lack of strong medical documentation.
Insurance companies do not simply rely on your diagnosis. They focus on functional limitations — how your condition prevents you from performing your job duties.
For example, saying “I have chronic pain” is not enough. The insurer will want to see:
- Detailed physician reports
- Specialist evaluations
- Objective testing results
- Clear explanations of physical or cognitive restrictions
If medical records are vague or incomplete, insurers may argue that your condition is not severe enough to prevent you from working.
Even legitimate claims can be denied if documentation does not clearly outline how your symptoms affect your ability to perform your job.
2. Failure to Meet the Policy Definition of Disability
Every long-term disability policy has a specific definition of “disability.”
Most policies in Toronto operate in two stages:
Own Occupation Period (usually first 24 months):
You must prove you cannot perform the essential duties of your own job.
Any Occupation Period (after 24 months):
You must prove you cannot perform any job that you are reasonably suited for based on your education, training, or experience.
Many claims are denied when this transition happens. Insurers may argue that while you cannot return to your previous job, you could work in a different capacity.
This shift often surprises claimants and leads to unexpected benefit terminations.
3. Inconsistent Medical Treatment
Insurance companies expect claimants to pursue ongoing treatment.
If you:
- Stop seeing your doctor regularly
- Do not follow prescribed treatment
- Decline recommended therapies
the insurer may argue that you are not truly disabled.
Even if your condition is stable and unlikely to improve, insurers often expect continued documentation. Gaps in treatment can raise red flags.
4. Surveillance and Social Media Monitoring
Many Toronto claimants are unaware that insurance companies may conduct surveillance.
Insurers sometimes hire investigators to:
- Monitor daily activities
- Record video footage
- Review social media accounts
If they capture footage of you performing activities that appear inconsistent with your reported limitations, they may use this to deny or terminate your claim.
For example, if you claim severe back pain but are seen carrying groceries or attending a social event, the insurer may question the severity of your disability — even if those activities caused pain afterward.
5. Pre-Existing Conditions
Another common reason for denial involves pre-existing conditions.
If you had prior medical issues before obtaining coverage, insurers may argue that your current disability is related to a condition that was not properly disclosed.
Some policies include clauses limiting benefits for pre-existing conditions, particularly within the first year of coverage.
Policy wording becomes extremely important in these cases.
6. Missed Deadlines or Incomplete Forms
Long-term disability claims involve detailed paperwork.
Common administrative issues that lead to denials include:
- Missing filing deadlines
- Incomplete application forms
- Failure to provide requested documentation
- Delayed submission of medical updates
Even small procedural errors can result in denial.
Insurance companies operate under strict internal timelines, and missing deadlines may weaken your claim.
7. Mental Health Claims Face Extra Scrutiny
Mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety, and PTSD are common reasons for disability claims in Toronto. However, these claims are often more heavily scrutinized.
Because mental health conditions are not visible on imaging tests, insurers may request:
- Psychiatric evaluations
- Detailed therapy records
- Independent medical examinations
In some cases, policies also limit the duration of benefits for mental health conditions.
Despite the legitimacy of these conditions, claimants may face additional hurdles.
8. Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs)
Insurance companies may require you to attend an Independent Medical Examination (IME).
Despite the name, these examinations are arranged and paid for by the insurer.
If the IME doctor concludes that you are capable of working — even in some limited capacity — the insurer may rely on that report to deny your claim.
These reports can sometimes conflict with your treating physician’s opinion.
9. Internal Insurance Review Practices
It’s important to understand that insurance companies are businesses.
Their goal is to manage financial risk. Claim approvals cost money.
While many claims are handled fairly, insurers carefully evaluate claims and often look for reasons to deny or limit benefits.
This does not mean your claim is invalid — it means the burden of proof rests heavily on you.
What Can You Do If Your Claim Is Denied?
A denial is not necessarily the end.
In Toronto, you may have options, including:
- Filing an internal appeal
- Providing additional medical evidence
- Consulting a long-term disability lawyer
- Pursuing legal action if necessary
Deadlines for appeals can be strict, so acting quickly is critical.
A disability lawyer can review your policy, analyze the reasons for denial, and help strengthen your case with additional documentation or expert opinions.
Read the article: 29 Times Court Conversations
Final Thoughts
Long-term disability claims are denied in Toronto for many reasons — but many denials are not the final word.
The most common issues involve insufficient medical evidence, policy definition disputes, surveillance findings, and procedural mistakes.
Understanding how insurers evaluate claims can help you avoid common pitfalls. Detailed medical documentation, consistent treatment, and careful attention to deadlines are essential.
If you are unable to work due to illness or injury, you deserve a fair review of your claim. A denial can feel discouraging, but with the right guidance and persistence, many claimants successfully challenge adverse decisions.
Protecting your financial stability during a period of disability is critical — and knowing why claims are denied is the first step toward strengthening your case.
